TopToolAdvisor
IT & security · Shortlist

10 Best Email Security Software of 2026

By the TopToolAdvisor research desk · Updated November 9, 2026 · Next review December 24, 2026 · 10 products scored

Our pickMicrosoft Defender for Office 365Organizations on Microsoft 365 that want strong phishing protection at the lowest per user price, managed from the same console as the rest of their Microsoft security.8.8

Our pick in brief

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is the default choice for any organization already on Microsoft 365, because Plan 1 adds link, attachment and language model phishing checks across email and Teams for $2 per user per month. Abnormal AI is the strongest specialist for BEC and vendor fraud that carries no malicious link or file. Material Security combines inbound email protection with account takeover and file sharing controls at a published price. Ironscales and Check Point deploy by API in minutes and add automated remediation, while Proofpoint and Mimecast remain the broadest platforms for large, complex mail estates. For small teams on a budget, Phish Protection and MailRoute publish simple per mailbox prices, and Paubox covers healthcare practices that need HIPAA encryption plus inbound filtering.

Quick answer

Microsoft Defender for Office 365 is the best email security software for IT teams on Microsoft 365 in 2026, from $2 per user per month paid yearly. Abnormal AI suits security teams that need behavioral detection of payload-free business email compromise, and Material Security suits Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 teams that want email and account security together from $4 per user per month. MailRoute is the cheapest filtering option at $2 per user per month with no contract.

This list is for IT and security teams that need to block phishing, business email compromise (BEC), vendor fraud and malware before staff act on them. We compared documented features and published prices for 10 email security products and scored each on features, ease of use and value. Prices are in US dollars as shown on each vendor's pricing page on the date we checked. Abnormal AI, Proofpoint, Mimecast, Check Point and Ironscales sell only on quote, so those entries show a pending price. The tools fall into two groups: API-based products that connect to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and remove threats inside the mailbox, and gateway or filtering services that sit in front of your mail server through an MX record change.

By the numbers

Shortlist scores

  1. 1Microsoft Defender for Office 365Organizations on Microsoft 365 that want strong phishing protection at the lowest per user price, managed from the same console as the rest of their Microsoft security.8.8
  2. 2Abnormal AIMid-market and enterprise security teams on Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace that need to stop payload-free BEC, vendor fraud and AI-written lures.8.5
  3. 3Material SecurityLean security teams on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 that want phishing defense plus account takeover and data protection at a published price.8.5
  4. 4Check Point Harmony Email & CollaborationIT teams that want inline blocking through an API deployment and coverage for Teams, Slack, SharePoint and OneDrive from one product.8.3
  5. 5IronscalesLean IT teams and MSPs that want hands-off phishing remediation and in-inbox warnings without an MX change.8.3
  6. 6MailRouteSmall businesses and regulated teams that want low-cost inbound and outbound filtering with no contract, including a US-only ITAR and HIPAA tier.8.2
  7. 7Phish ProtectionSmall businesses that want full anti-phishing features with self-serve monthly pricing and no contract.8.2
  8. 8Proofpoint Core Email ProtectionLarge enterprises with complex mail flows that want both gateway and API protection, domain fraud defense and deep threat intelligence from one vendor.8.1
  9. 9Mimecast Advanced Email SecurityOrganizations with hybrid or on-premises mail that want MX-based filtering plus continuity, archiving and awareness training from one platform.7.9
  10. 10PauboxHealthcare practices and vendors that need HIPAA encrypted email and inbound phishing protection in one subscription.7.7

How the scores work

Each product is rated out of 10 on the same three criteria, then ranked by the weighted total. Scores compare documented features and published prices, not hands-on testing.

  • 35%Features
  • 35%Ease of use
  • 30%Value

Read the scoring method

  1. No. 1, our pick

    Microsoft Defender for Office 365

    Microsoft's add-on protection for Exchange Online, Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive against phishing, malicious links, malware and BEC.

    8.8of 10

    Best for Organizations on Microsoft 365 that want strong phishing protection at the lowest per user price, managed from the same console as the rest of their Microsoft security.

    Features
    8.8
    Ease of use
    8.4
    Value
    9.4

    Price

    Plan 1 from $2 per user per month paid yearly; Plan 2 $5 per user per month

    Quoted from the Microsoft Defender for Office 365 pricing page on November 9, 2026: $2.00 user/month, paid yearly

    Defender for Office 365 earns the top spot because it gives Microsoft 365 tenants a large step up in phishing defense for very little money. Plan 1, at $2 per user per month paid yearly, adds real-time checks on links and QR codes, detonation of attachments for zero-day malware, language model based analysis aimed at phishing and BEC, and protection for internal mail. It covers Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive, which matters as attackers move into chat and shared files. Plan 2, at $5, adds threat hunting, campaign tracking, attack simulation training and automated investigation and response, plus cross-domain hunting in Defender XDR. Microsoft also publishes its own detection performance data, which helps when you compare it with third-party tools. The limits are scope and complexity: it does nothing for Google Workspace, and tuning its policies across Microsoft's admin portals takes practice. Specialist tools still catch some BEC it misses, so many teams layer one on top, but for most Microsoft 365 shops this is where to start.

    Strengths

    • +Plan 1 costs $2 per user per month, the lowest published price here for API-level Microsoft 365 protection
    • +Covers Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive as well as mailboxes
    • +Plan 2 links email incidents with endpoint and identity data in Defender XDR

    Drawbacks

    • −Only protects Microsoft 365; no Google Workspace coverage
    • −Attack simulation training and automated response need Plan 2
    • −Policy settings spread across several Microsoft portals take time to learn
    Plans
    Plan 1, Plan 2, Microsoft Defender Suite
    Plan 2 price
    $5 per user per month, paid yearly
    Platforms
    Microsoft 365 email, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive
    Free trial
    Yes, on Plan 1 and Plan 2

    Visit microsoft.com|See the Microsoft Defender for Office 365 profile

  2. No. 2

    Abnormal AI

    An API-based inbound email security platform that builds a behavioral baseline for every employee and vendor to catch BEC and social engineering.

    8.5of 10

    Best for Mid-market and enterprise security teams on Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace that need to stop payload-free BEC, vendor fraud and AI-written lures.

    Features
    9.5
    Ease of use
    9.0
    Value
    6.8

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    We could not confirm a US price yet. Check the Abnormal AI pricing page.

    Abnormal AI is the specialist pick for the attacks that worry finance and security teams most: business email compromise and vendor fraud that carry no malicious payload and pass every authentication check. Its Attune 1.0 model builds a behavioral baseline for each employee and vendor, then flags messages that depart from it, using signals such as authentication events, calendar activity and internal threads. Malicious messages and calendar invites are removed automatically, and every action shows which signals fired. Analysts get search and respond across Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, a single quarantine view for Abnormal and Microsoft, custom AI models written in plain language, and custom rules on more than 50 message attributes. Detection 360 turns each reported miss or false positive into a tracked investigation. Because it connects by API, there is no MX change. The trade-off is cost visibility: Abnormal publishes no prices, and its depth is aimed at organizations with a security team rather than a single IT generalist.

    Strengths

    • +Built for attacks with no link, file or authentication failure, the core of BEC
    • +Reads authentication events, calendar activity and internal threads, not only inbound mail
    • +Unified quarantine review for Abnormal and Microsoft in one place

    Drawbacks

    • −No published price; every deal is a sales quote
    • −Focused on Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, not on-premises mail servers
    • −More than a small business with a few dozen mailboxes usually needs
    Deployment
    API connection to Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
    Detection model
    Attune 1.0 per-identity behavioral baselines
    Custom rules
    50+ message attributes
    Pricing
    Quote based

    Visit abnormal.ai|See the Abnormal AI profile

  3. No. 3

    Material Security

    A cloud workspace security platform for Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 that combines inbound email threat response with account, file and OAuth app security.

    8.5of 10

    Best for Lean security teams on Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 that want phishing defense plus account takeover and data protection at a published price.

    Features
    8.4
    Ease of use
    8.5
    Value
    8.6

    Price

    Essentials from $4 per user per month billed annually, plus a fee based on Shared Drive size

    Quoted from the Material Security pricing page on November 9, 2026: $4 Per user/month, billed annually Plus fee based on Shared Drive size

    Material Security takes a wider view than most email tools: it treats the mailbox as part of the cloud workspace and protects the accounts and files around it. Essentials, at $4 per user per month billed annually plus a fee tied to Shared Drive size, includes automated detection and response for phishing, BEC, impersonation and fraud, an agent that processes user-reported phish, email bomb detection, threat hunting with custom detections, and training touches such as speedbumps and simulations. It also inventories connected OAuth apps and flags posture problems such as MFA gaps, inactive accounts and mail forwarding. Advanced, at $6, adds sensitive content detection in Shared Drives and email and agentic OAuth remediation. The ATO Resilience add-on, $3 more, puts message-level MFA in front of sensitive and password reset emails so a stolen login does less damage. The drawbacks are the separate Shared Drive fee and that some mailbox types need a quote. For Google Workspace shops in particular, it is one of the few tools that covers email and account risk at a published price.

    Strengths

    • +Published prices: Essentials $4, Advanced $6, ATO Resilience add-on $3 per user per month
    • +Covers account takeover and file sharing risk as well as inbound phishing
    • +Email bomb detection and threat hunting with custom detections on the entry plan

    Drawbacks

    • −Extra fee based on Shared Drive size on top of the per user price
    • −Sensitive content detection in files and email needs the Advanced plan
    • −Shared, service and student mailbox pricing needs a sales conversation
    Plans
    Essentials, Advanced, Enterprise, ATO Resilience add-on
    Advanced price
    $6 per user per month, billed annually
    Platforms
    Google Workspace and Microsoft 365
    Email content retention
    Unlimited

    Visit material.security|See the Material Security profile

  4. No. 4

    Check Point Harmony Email & Collaboration

    A prevention-first email and collaboration security platform that inspects messages before they reach the inbox across Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and chat apps.

    8.3of 10

    Best for IT teams that want inline blocking through an API deployment and coverage for Teams, Slack, SharePoint and OneDrive from one product.

    Features
    9.2
    Ease of use
    8.6
    Value
    7.0

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    We could not confirm a US price yet. Check the Check Point Harmony Email & Collaboration pricing page.

    Check Point's email product stands out for blocking threats before delivery while still connecting by API. Most API tools pull bad mail out after it lands, but Check Point inspects each message first and can run in monitor mode during evaluation, then move to inline prevention without touching MX records. Detection runs through ThreatCloud AI, which Check Point says combines more than 50 AI engines with behavioral, identity and language analysis and global threat intelligence. Coverage reaches beyond Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace mail to Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive and Slack. It also screens for malicious prompts and hidden instructions aimed at AI assistants such as Copilot and Gemini that read email. The Complete package layers on DLP, DMARC, security awareness training, account takeover protection and archiving. Pricing is quote only and the package matrix takes some reading, but for teams that want one tool across mail and chat with prevention before the inbox, it is a strong fit.

    Strengths

    • +Inline prevention through an API connection avoids the post-delivery gap
    • +Guards AI assistants such as Copilot and Gemini against malicious prompts hidden in email
    • +Broad collaboration coverage beyond the mailbox

    Drawbacks

    • −No published prices
    • −Packages split email-only and email plus collaboration tiers, which adds quoting steps
    • −Feature breadth means more policy to configure than single-purpose tools
    AI engines
    50+
    Organizations protected
    80K+
    Deployment
    API with monitor or inline prevention modes
    Free trial
    Yes

    Visit checkpoint.com|See the Check Point Harmony Email & Collaboration profile

  5. No. 5

    Ironscales

    An API-based email security platform that combines adaptive AI with crowdsourced threat intelligence and automated remediation for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace.

    8.3of 10

    Best for Lean IT teams and MSPs that want hands-off phishing remediation and in-inbox warnings without an MX change.

    Features
    8.7
    Ease of use
    8.8
    Value
    7.4

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    We could not confirm a US price yet. Check the Ironscales pricing page.

    Ironscales is built for teams that cannot staff a full email security desk. It connects to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace by API, so there is no MX change or gateway, and its agentic AI removes phishing, spam and graymail on its own. Email Essentials already includes detection for phishing, BEC and VIP impersonation, dynamic warning banners inside messages, a Report Phishing add-in for Outlook, crowdsourced threat intelligence and URL scanning. Email Protect adds multi-engine scanning of links and attachments, advanced spam handling and control over how far remediation runs on its own. Email Protect 360 adds encryption and data loss prevention for outbound mail. Domain lookalike detection and protection against QR code and image-based phishing round out the detection set. Ironscales also runs a partner program for MSPs. The catch is that no tier has a public price, and attachment sandboxing is not in the entry plan, so compare tiers carefully before you request a quote.

    Strengths

    • +Deploys in minutes with no MX changes and no gateway
    • +Crowdsourced intelligence feeds user reports back into detection
    • +Clear three-tier path from Email Essentials to Email Protect 360

    Drawbacks

    • −Every tier is quote only
    • −Malicious attachment scanning starts on Email Protect, not Email Essentials
    • −Encryption and DLP only in the top tier
    Plans
    Email Essentials, Email Protect, Email Protect 360
    Deployment
    API, no MX change
    Platforms
    Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
    Pricing
    Quote based

    Visit ironscales.com|See the Ironscales profile

  6. No. 6

    MailRoute

    A hosted email filtering service that adds spam, virus, content and impersonation filtering in front of an existing mail system, with continuity on higher tiers.

    8.2of 10

    Best for Small businesses and regulated teams that want low-cost inbound and outbound filtering with no contract, including a US-only ITAR and HIPAA tier.

    Features
    7.0
    Ease of use
    8.6
    Value
    9.2

    Price

    Basics from $2 per user per month; Enterprise $3; Enterprise U.S. $4

    Quoted from the MailRoute pricing page on November 9, 2026: Basics $2 /user/mo Small business & personal domains

    MailRoute is a straightforward filtering service that sits in front of your mail server and publishes its price list in full. Basics costs $2 per user per month and includes inbound and outbound security, content filtering, DKIM signing, quarantine notifications, real-time mail logs and integration with Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace. Impersonation protection is available on all plans in early access. Enterprise, at $3, adds phone support, SSO, LDAP and Active Directory sync, an API, white-glove onboarding and an always-on 30-day email continuity store users can reach during outages. Enterprise U.S., at $4, keeps data in US datacenters with US-citizen-only access, and supports ITAR, HIPAA with a BAA and NIST 800-171. Every tier queues mail for up to 15 days if your server stops responding. Aliases and distribution lists cost nothing, and there are no seat minimums or contracts. What it lacks is behavioral detection of BEC and post-delivery removal, so treat it as a dependable filter and outage buffer rather than a full anti-BEC platform.

    Strengths

    • +Published prices from $2 per user per month with no seat minimums or contracts
    • +Aliases and distribution lists are free on filtering plans
    • +Self-serve setup that most customers finish in under 30 minutes, per MailRoute

    Drawbacks

    • −Impersonation protection is still early access
    • −Gateway style filtering cannot remove mail already in inboxes
    • −No behavioral AI for BEC; best paired with a native or API layer
    Plans
    Basics, Enterprise, Enterprise U.S.
    Enterprise price
    $3 per user per month
    Outage queueing
    Up to 15 days on every plan
    Contract
    No long-term contracts

    Visit mailroute.net|See the MailRoute profile

  7. No. 7

    Phish Protection

    A filtering service from DuoCircle that blocks phishing, ransomware and BEC with time-of-click link checks and attachment sandboxing for any mail platform.

    8.2of 10

    Best for Small businesses that want full anti-phishing features with self-serve monthly pricing and no contract.

    Features
    7.2
    Ease of use
    8.8
    Value
    8.8

    Price

    $32 per month base fee including 10 users, then from $1.80 per extra user per month

    Quoted from the Phish Protection pricing page on November 9, 2026: Base fee: $32/mo (includes 10 users).

    Phish Protection, run by DuoCircle, is one of the few email security services that shows its full price on the website and lets you buy without a sales call. The base fee is $32 per month and covers 10 users, then each additional mailbox costs $1.80 per month, falling to $1.60 at larger volumes, and shared mailboxes cost half. Every plan includes the same features: real-time protection, advanced threat defense with AI-powered URL analysis, time-of-click link checks, attachment sandboxing, display name spoofing detection, blocklists and allowlists, and a reporting dashboard. It works with Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and any mail system that supports standard routing, and support is 24/7 and US based. There is a 60-day free trial with no credit card and no long-term contract. The trade-off is depth: it is a filtering layer rather than an API tool that learns each user's normal behavior, so it is weaker against carefully written BEC with no link or file. For a small office that wants solid phishing filtering on a known budget, it is easy to recommend.

    Strengths

    • +Every plan includes the full feature set, with no feature gating
    • +60-day free trial with no credit card
    • +Shared mailboxes billed at 50% of the user rate

    Drawbacks

    • −Filtering service, so setup changes mail routing rather than connecting by API
    • −No behavioral baselining of senders for payload-free BEC
    • −Annual billing discounts need a sales contact
    Per user price
    $1.80 per user per month for 1 to 25 users, falling to $1.60 at 501 to 1,000
    Domain aliases
    $50 per month each, users at 50% off
    Support
    24/7 US-based
    Contract
    None, cancel anytime

    Visit phishprotection.com|See the Phish Protection profile

  8. No. 8

    Proofpoint Core Email Protection

    Proofpoint's AI email security for Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace, deployable by API or as a secure email gateway, covering phishing, BEC and ransomware.

    8.1of 10

    Best for Large enterprises with complex mail flows that want both gateway and API protection, domain fraud defense and deep threat intelligence from one vendor.

    Features
    9.6
    Ease of use
    7.6
    Value
    6.8

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    We could not confirm a US price yet. Check the Proofpoint Core Email Protection pricing page.

    Proofpoint is the heavyweight option for large organizations that want one vendor across every stage of email delivery. Core Email Protection can run as a secure email gateway, through an API connection to Microsoft 365 via Microsoft Graph, or both, which gives inline, in-mailbox, post-delivery and click-time coverage. Detection uses multi-model behavioral AI trained on Proofpoint's view of threat campaigns, and the Threat Protection Workbench brings inbound, internal, account and supplier compromise into one investigation view. Users see dynamic warning banners on suspicious mail, and the Satori Abuse Mailbox Agent automates the triage of reported messages. Proofpoint also adds domain fraud detection and takedown and outbound data controls, which few rivals bundle. Detections can appear inside the Microsoft 365 console for analysts who live there. The costs are price opacity and operational weight: there is no published price, and the range of modules takes skilled staff to tune. For a global enterprise with gateway requirements, it remains one of the most complete choices, but smaller teams will find simpler tools easier to run.

    Strengths

    • +Only product here that pairs gateway and API protection with domain fraud detection and takedown
    • +Proofpoint detections visible inside the Microsoft 365 console
    • +Covers outbound threats and sensitive data as well as inbound attacks

    Drawbacks

    • −No published prices
    • −Breadth of modules makes setup and tuning heavier than API-only tools
    • −Small businesses are served by a separate Proofpoint Essentials product
    Deployment
    API, SEG, or both
    API setup time
    About 48 hours via Microsoft Graph, per Proofpoint
    Platforms
    Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
    Pricing
    Quote based

    Visit proofpoint.com|See the Proofpoint Core Email Protection profile

  9. No. 9

    Mimecast Advanced Email Security

    Email security for Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and on-premises mail, delivered with or without a gateway and connected to continuity, DMARC and archiving.

    7.9of 10

    Best for Organizations with hybrid or on-premises mail that want MX-based filtering plus continuity, archiving and awareness training from one platform.

    Features
    9.0
    Ease of use
    7.6
    Value
    6.8

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    We could not confirm a US price yet. Check the Mimecast Advanced Email Security pricing page.

    Mimecast suits organizations whose mail is not purely in the cloud. It protects Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and on-premises or hybrid environments, and you can deploy it as an MX-based gateway that blocks bad mail in line or without a gateway. Detection combines anomaly detection based on social graphing, sandboxing to catch evasive files, on-click link protection and computer vision that spots brand and login page impersonation. Contextual banners warn users in the message and support remediation of threats such as QR code phishing and BEC. The platform connects to SIEM and XDR tools for shared threat intelligence, and adds Mimecast's own Continuity, DMARC, security awareness training and Archiving modules, so one vendor can cover filtering, outage access and retention. Mimecast says 42,000 customers use it. The downsides are a quote-only model, more setup for gateway deployments and a larger set of modules to manage. If your estate is hybrid or you want archiving and continuity with your filter, it is a sound choice; cloud-only teams can get faster results from API tools.

    Strengths

    • +Supports on-premises and hybrid mail, not only cloud suites
    • +Bundles continuity and archiving that pure API tools lack
    • +Granular policy controls and user segmentation

    Drawbacks

    • −Quote only, with no published price
    • −Gateway deployments need MX changes and more setup
    • −Many modules to license and manage
    Customers
    42,000, per Mimecast
    Deployment
    MX-based gateway or gateway-free
    Platforms
    Microsoft 365, Google Workspace, on-premises, hybrid
    Pricing
    Quote based

    Visit mimecast.com|See the Mimecast Advanced Email Security profile

  10. No. 10

    Paubox

    HIPAA compliant email for Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 that encrypts outbound mail automatically and adds inbound protection on its Plus plan.

    7.7of 10

    Best for Healthcare practices and vendors that need HIPAA encrypted email and inbound phishing protection in one subscription.

    Features
    7.0
    Ease of use
    8.6
    Value
    7.6

    Price

    Plus from $65 per month billed annually for up to 5 senders

    Quoted from the Paubox pricing page on November 9, 2026: HIPAA compliant email + email security $ 65 /month Up to 5 senders

    Paubox is a specialist for healthcare, where email security has to cover HIPAA as well as phishing. Its Plus plan, the entry point for inbound protection, costs $65 per month billed annually for up to five senders. Plus filters inbound mail for spam, ransomware and phishing, adds malware and virus scanning, and uses ExecProtect+ to stop display name spoofing of practice leaders. It keeps the core of every Paubox plan: outbound email is encrypted automatically and recipients read it without a portal or password, which patients appreciate. Paubox works with Google Workspace and Microsoft 365, includes a business associate agreement, is HITRUST certified and offers US-based support. Premium, at $75, adds archiving and data loss prevention. The limits are scope and scale: it is not built for behavioral BEC detection in large organizations, and sender-based pricing climbs as headcount grows. For a clinic or a health tech vendor that needs compliant encryption and decent inbound filtering from one provider, it fits well.

    Strengths

    • +Business associate agreement included with every plan
    • +Recipients read encrypted mail without portals or passwords
    • +HITRUST certified, with US-based phone and email support

    Drawbacks

    • −Inbound security needs Plus; the Standard plan covers encryption only
    • −Priced by senders, which gets expensive for larger staff counts
    • −Aimed at healthcare compliance rather than broad BEC defense
    Plans
    Standard, Plus, Premium
    Premium price
    $75 per month for up to 5 senders, billed annually
    Platforms
    Google Workspace and Microsoft 365
    Free trial
    14 days

    Visit paubox.com|See the Paubox profile

What to check before you buy

Decide between API and gateway deployment

API-based tools such as Abnormal AI, Ironscales, Material Security and Check Point connect to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace without an MX change and can pull threats out of inboxes after delivery. Gateway and filtering services such as MailRoute, Phish Protection and the MX option in Mimecast scan mail before it reaches your server. Proofpoint and Check Point offer both modes, which helps if you want inline blocking on some mail flows.

Test for payload-free BEC, not only malware

Invoice fraud and executive impersonation messages often contain no link or attachment, so signature and sandbox checks miss them. Ask each vendor how it models normal sender and recipient behavior, and run a trial in monitor mode so you can compare what it flags against what your current filter let through.

Check what happens after a user reports a phish

Security teams spend much of their email time on user reports. Material Security, Proofpoint and Ironscales describe automated handling of reported phishing, and Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 2 adds automated investigation and response. Fewer manual triage steps matter more than one extra detection engine for a small team.

Count every mailbox type in the price

Vendors define a user differently. Phish Protection bills shared mailboxes at half rate, MailRoute treats aliases and distribution lists as free on filtering plans, and Material Security asks you to contact sales about service and shared mailboxes. Paubox prices by number of senders. Build the same mailbox count for every quote.

Look past the inbox if attackers already target Teams and files

Phishing now arrives through chat and shared files as well as email. Defender for Office 365 covers Teams, SharePoint and OneDrive, Check Point adds Slack and other collaboration apps, and Material Security watches Shared Drive sharing and connected OAuth apps. If those channels matter to you, weigh that coverage in the comparison.

Common questions

What is email security software?
Email security software screens inbound and outbound mail for phishing, business email compromise, malware, spam and impersonation. API-based tools connect to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace and remove threats inside the mailbox, while gateway or filtering services scan mail before it reaches your server.
How much does email security software cost?
Among vendors that publish prices, Microsoft Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 costs $2 per user per month paid yearly, MailRoute Basics $2 per user per month, Material Security Essentials $4 per user per month billed annually, Phish Protection $32 per month for 10 users and Paubox Plus $65 per month for up to five senders billed annually. Abnormal AI, Proofpoint, Mimecast, Check Point and Ironscales quote on request.
Is Microsoft's built-in protection enough to stop phishing?
Defender for Office 365 adds link, attachment and language model phishing checks across email and Teams, and it is a strong first layer for Microsoft 365 tenants. Many security teams add a specialist such as Abnormal AI or Ironscales when a trial shows BEC or vendor fraud still reaching inboxes.
What is the difference between API and gateway email security?
A gateway, or secure email gateway, sits in front of your mail server through an MX record change and filters mail before delivery. An API tool connects directly to Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, needs no MX change and can pull threats out of inboxes after delivery. Proofpoint and Check Point support both styles.
Which email security tool is best for small businesses?
Microsoft 365 users should start with Defender for Office 365 Plan 1 at $2 per user per month. Businesses on other platforms or wanting a separate filter can use MailRoute from $2 per user per month or Phish Protection at $32 per month for 10 users, both without long contracts.

Questions or corrections: editorial@toptooladvisor.com

No affiliate links and no paid placement; see our disclosure and editorial policy. Vendors update prices without notice, so confirm on their site first.

Related shortlists